When glass meets minimalism: Edward James and his Art Deco glass lamps

This blog was originally written by MA Conservation Studies students Rose Zhou, Sujin Jung, and Rick Li for the Corning Museum of Glass website. Rose, Sujin, and Rick undertook a five week work placement with The Corning Museum of Glass, working virtually with their Conservation Department to develop their understanding of glass conservation and what it means to be a conservator in a museum setting. For this post, they have applied that knowledge to examine objects in the West Dean Collection.

Explore Categories

MA Conservation Studies students, from left to right, Rick Li, Rose Zhou, and Sujin Jung, in the Old Library at West Dean College
MA Conservation Studies students, from left to right, Rick Li, Rose Zhou, and Sujin Jung, in the Old Library at West Dean College

The global pandemic has impacted a lot of people’s study, work, and life. For us, three conservation students, our work placements at external conservation labs were interrupted. This is when our tutor reached out to the Conservation Department of The Corning Museum of Glass, who kindly offered us a five-week online work placement from the other side of the Atlantic Ocean!

During these five weeks, Astrid van Giffen, associate conservator, and Lianne Uesato, assistant conservator, from Corning’s Conservation Department customised a brief but fantastic journey into the glass world for us through a series of lectures and demonstrations. With the help from colleagues from other departments at the Museum, we had the chance to peek into a conservator’s daily life to see beyond lab work to the collaborative teamwork among departments. All of these are extremely valuable experiences for us to get a feel for working in a museum.

While we were doing a collection survey project of ceramics at the College, this work placement also inspired us to look at the glass collection from a new perspective. We had many options, as the collection includes a wide variety of glass objects ranging from Roman glass vessels to medieval, 17th century, 19th century, and modern stained glass, historic chandeliers, glass tableware, and glass elements associated with interior design. In this blog, we intend to briefly introduce the glass collection from a conservation perspective, with a particular focus on the art deco glass lamps.

Besides his engagement in the art world, College Founder Edward James also expressed his artistic vision through the interior design of his homes. Although many of them no longer exist, his avant-garde spirit can be seen in the personal possessions he left behind. When looking into the West Dean Collection, we found that he showed a specific interest in lamps. It is hard to find a single word to generalize his lamp collection, as clearly, James treated each lamp not only as a lighting source but also as a part of an innovative “personality” for each room. In particular, a group of art deco glass lamps caught our interest.

The first objects are a pair of glass standard lamps designed by Jean-Michel Frank in circa 1928. They were supplied to Edward James in circa 1930 for the interior decoration of his home at 35 Wimpole Street, London. Jean-Michel Frank (1895-1941) was a French interior designer known for his minimalist and classic modernist ideas. This pair of lamps clearly conveys his aesthetics, with plain lines and elegant form. The central square pillar of each lamp was made of nine glass sheets layered together, inserted at the top and bottom in patinated bronze cubes. The thickness of the layered glass sheets enhances the greenish-blue hue of the glass but keeps the translucent and refractive quality. The circular base is also made of the same patinated bronze material, topped by four glass quarters that create a mirror effect.

A pair of Standard Lamps with Layered Glass, Patinated Bronze, and Aluminum, designed by Jean-Michel Frank circa 1928, West Dean Collection, photo courtesy of Rose Zhou
A pair of Standard Lamps with Layered Glass, Patinated Bronze, and Aluminum, designed by Jean-Michel Frank circa 1928, West Dean Collection, photo courtesy of Rose Zhou
Detail of the layered glass design and the patinated bronze cube at the top, photo courtesy of Rose Zhou.
Detail of the layered glass design and the patinated bronze cube at the top, photo courtesy of Rose Zhou.

Under close investigation, contaminants including dust and small bugs can be seen between the glass layers which dull the visual quality of the glass pillar. This suggests that there is no adhesive in between the glass sheets to glue them together. There are also small “halos” forming around the bug bodies, which suggests localized deterioration. Moisture trapped with the bugs and other organic materials may be slowly reacting with the glass surface to cause corrosion. While cleaning is obviously the best way to remove the sources of corrosion, the risk of dismantling the object for cleaning purposes needs to be considered as part of the decision-making process. Meanwhile, cleaning can only temporarily improve the appearance. The same situation is likely to happen again over time because of the design of the piece. This is what a conservator would call an “inherent vice” of the object.

Detail of the contaminants in between the glass layers, photo courtesy of Rose Zhou.
Detail of the contaminants in between the glass layers, photo courtesy of Rose Zhou.

The second object is a glass and chrome table lamp. The existing archival records do not offer any information about the maker, but it is strongly believed that it was also Jean-Michel Frank who designed this object.

Glass and Chrome Table Lamp, designed by Jean-Michel Frank circa 1940s, West Dean Collection, photo courtesy of Sujin Jung.
Glass and Chrome Table Lamp, designed by Jean-Michel Frank circa 1940s, West Dean Collection, photo courtesy of Sujin Jung.

A significant number of artifacts by Frank in an identical design but different materials were found. The design of this object, with a cruciform stem, is called “Croisillon” in French. Research showed that Frank’s “Croisillon” lamp was executed in several materials such as painted iron, oak, gilt bronze, painted bronze, brass, and glass. This pair, from a Sotheby’s auction in 2020, is one of the examples made in painted bronze. As most of the objects in the same design were made in the 1940s, the table lamp might also have been created around the same period.

Another reason to suspect this object is Jean-Michel Frank’s work is that the colour and structural use of the glass is very similar to the pair of standard glass lamps. The medium of this object is almost the same light green hue flat glass, with five flat glass sheets layered together to form a thick panel in a similar manner. Four glass panels constitute the “Croisillon” structure on a chrome metal base. Frank pursued simple forms with clarity but gave an accent with unexpected materials. Compared to the same design in other materials, layering the flat glasses gives a striking visual effect based on the simple structure, with the cruciform design refracts the light in a scattering way. However, the absence of archival records leads to more guesses. It will be worth investigating the authenticity of this object further.

Detail of chip, photo courtesy of Sujin Jung.
Detail of chip, photo courtesy of Sujin Jung.
Detail of the replaced rivet and the foam pad. Detail of the condition of the metal base, photo courtesy of Sujin Jung.
Detail of the replaced rivet and the foam pad. Detail of the condition of the metal base, photo courtesy of Sujin Jung.

The condition of the object is generally good except for general surface dirt. Dust between the glass sheets is observed. There are two small chips to the glass sheets. Five glass sheets of each cross-wing are held with rivets on the bottom, one of which is replaced previously with a rivet in different metal and an additional foam pad. The glass sheets are slightly wobbly. Metal components have some tiny black dots and scratches, but the metal itself does not show any deterioration. The metal base shows extensive scratches, probably caused during the assembly process.

The third object is this early 20th-century four-tier glass globe table lamp. Not much information is available regarding its design or origin, but Art Deco influence can be seen in its minimal aesthetic. It consists of four identical clear glass globes stacked on the vertical metal stem of the table lamp, with a bulb holder at the top.

Glass and Chromed Metal Table Lamp, early 20th century, West Dean Collection, photo © West Dean College of Arts and Conservation
Glass and Chromed Metal Table Lamp, early 20th century, West Dean Collection, photo © West Dean College of Arts and Conservation

This object may be missing a lampshade and metal fitting. Other parts of the table lamp are in relatively good condition, including the glass globes to the chrome metal base. This object can be compared with a similar object within the collection, with two-tier glass globes stacked on the stem instead of four (pictured below). While the comparison object is also missing the lampshade, its metal fitting suggests how the shade may have looked. The shape of the fitting could be an important reference for potential conservation treatments for the four-tier glass globe lamp.
 

Glass and Chromed Metal Table Lamp, early 20th century, West Dean Collection, photo © West Dean College of Arts and Conservation
Glass and Chromed Metal Table Lamp, early 20th century, West Dean Collection, photo © West Dean College of Arts and Conservation

These two objects are currently kept in a glass cabinet with dedicated environmental monitoring in place. Although well preserved over the decades, signs of aging can be observed on the elastic cables as well as the underside of the metal base. Preventive intervention may be required to check the risk of the degradation, which will involve consultation with the College’s collection manager. Perhaps assessment by metal conservation students will be required to check the conditions of the metal base, such as the potential issue of rust.

Together, these items exemplify a particular group of glass objects as daily functional objects that convey a design value. Without elaborate decorative details, the glass itself, as a unified transparent solid with brilliant light refractive quality, can be appreciated. At the same time, these characteristics provide a perfect foil for the minimalist aesthetic and turn the glass into a supporting role. In short, while the key element of the object is obviously the glass, the essence of the object is no longer the material but the design. This poses a lot of interesting questions when it comes to conservation decision-making. How should the missing parts be replaced when the visual perception of the object is interrupted? How should “inherit vices” be considered when treating these modern objects? How should they be displayed to best fulfill their value? Ultimately, are we conserving the object, or are we conserving an idea?

There is no definite answer to any of these questions, which makes each project an adventure for the conservator to seek the best solution – and that’s all part of the fun!

References:

Christies, 2016. A Surreal Legacy: Selected Works of Art from the Edward James Foundation. [online] Available at: https://www.christies.com/en/auction/auction-13765-cks  [Accessed 9 April 2021].

Christies, 2002. A Glass and Bronze Table Lamp Designed by Jean-Michel Frank, circa 1930-35. [online] Available at: https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-2040525  [Accessed 9 April 2021].

Lowe, J. (1991) Edward James, poet, patron, eccentric: a surrealist life. London: Collins.

Owens, M., 1999. Jean-Michel Frank, The prolific genius of Modernist French design. Architectural Digest. [online] Available at: https://www.architecturaldigest.com/story/frank-article-012000   [Accessed 9 April 2021].

Sothebys, 2021. JEAN-MICHEL FRANK | PAIR OF “CROISILLON” TABLE LAMPS. [online] Available at: https://www.sothebys.com/en/buy/auction/2020/design-2/jean-michel-frank-pair-of-croisillon-table-lamps [Accessed 9 April 2021].

Tate Etc, 2016. From the Surreal to the Decorative. [online] Available at: https://www.tate.org.uk/tate-etc/issue-38-autumn-2016/surreal-decorative [Accessed 9 April 2021].

Teitelbaum, M.A., 2010. The stylemakers: minimalism and classic modernism 1915 – 1945. London: Philip Wilson Publishers.

Weaver, B., 2021. Jean-Michel Frank. Londonlist, [online] Available at: https://www.thelondonlist.com/culture/jean-michel-frank-lighting [Accessed 9 April 2021].

West Dean College of Arts and Conservation, 2021. History and Edward James. [online] Available at: https://www.westdean.org.uk/about/history-and-edward-james [Accessed 9 April 2021].

About The Corning Museum of Glass

The Corning Museum of Glass is the foremost authority on the art, history, science, and design of glass. It is home to the world’s most important collection of glass, including the finest examples of glassmaking spanning 3,500 years.